SIEM vs. XDR: Choosing the Right Log Security Solution for SMBs in 2025

Struggling to pick between SIEM and XDR for your SMB’s cybersecurity in 2025? Here's the quick answer:

• Choose SIEM if compliance, customisation, and long-term log storage are your priorities.

• Choose XDR if you need automated threat detection, AI-powered analytics, and simpler workflows.

• Consider both (Hybrid) if you need to balance compliance with advanced threat response.

Quick Comparison

Key takeaway: SIEM is ideal for compliance-heavy tasks, while XDR excels in resource-efficient threat detection. SMBs often benefit from a hybrid approach to get the best of both worlds.

SIEM vs XDR: Main Technical Differences

SIEM Platform Functions

SIEM platforms are designed to collect and analyze logs from a variety of sources. Here's what they bring to the table:

• Broad Data Collection: They gather logs from firewalls, servers, network devices, and more.

• Customisable Analysis: Users can create custom detection rules and correlations tailored to their specific needs.

• Compliance Reporting: These platforms generate detailed audit trails and documentation to meet compliance requirements.

• Historical Data Access: They maintain searchable archives of past security events for investigation and analysis.

XDR Platform Functions

XDR takes the foundational capabilities of SIEM and adds a layer of advanced features that enhance security operations:

• AI-Driven Analytics: Artificial intelligence is used to detect, rank, and prioritize threats effectively.

• Automated Response: Incident response workflows are streamlined, saving time and resources.

• Cross-Surface Integration: Security efforts are coordinated across endpoints, networks, and cloud environments.

• Data Processing: XDR focuses on efficiently processing and prioritizing security-relevant data.

These advancements make XDR particularly appealing for small and medium-sized businesses (SMBs) looking for efficient and resource-conscious threat detection solutions.

Feature Comparison Table

Here's a side-by-side look at how SIEM and XDR differ in their technical capabilities:

"Now, many XDR providers have reached a point of integration and product capability where customers can start realizing the SIEM replacement vision, even if XDR still can't compete for more niche SIEM use cases such as compliance, federated search, and heavy customization" [1].

The way these platforms handle data highlights their key differences. SIEM excels in managing large volumes of unstructured log data, making it ideal for compliance and audit purposes. On the other hand, XDR focuses on normalising and prioritising data that's directly relevant to security, often leveraging AI to enhance efficiency. In fact, AI capabilities were cited over 75 times in vendor responses to Forrester's evaluation criteria for vision, innovation, and roadmap [1]. This growing reliance on automation and intelligence reflects a shift toward more streamlined and resource-efficient security practices.

SMB Use Cases: SIEM vs XDR in Practice

Now that we've covered the technical differences, let's dive into how these platforms can deliver practical advantages for SMBs.

SIEM Benefits for SMBs

For SMBs navigating compliance challenges and managing complex logs, SIEM platforms are a great fit. Their standout feature is their ability to handle large volumes of data efficiently. SIEM can automate tasks like maintaining audit trails and generating compliance reports, which is especially useful for meeting stringent RGPD requirements.

"SIEM is a configurable security system of record that aggregates and analyzes security event data from on-premises and cloud environments. SIEM assists with response actions to mitigate issues that cause harm to the organization and satisfy compliance and reporting requirements." [2]

XDR Benefits for SMBs

XDR leverages advanced analytics, powered by AI, making it ideal for SMBs with limited IT resources. This technology brings enterprise-level security within reach for smaller organisations by automating threat detection and streamlining responses.

Here’s how XDR stands out for SMBs:

Combined SIEM-XDR Setup

For many SMBs, a hybrid approach that combines SIEM and XDR offers the best of both worlds. This strategy allows businesses to address compliance and log management with SIEM while taking advantage of XDR's automated threat detection and response capabilities.

When adopting this combined setup, SMBs should focus on securing endpoints, managing identities, and protecting email systems - areas where XDR typically shines. Meanwhile, the SIEM component can handle broader compliance tasks and custom log management that go beyond XDR's scope. This balanced approach ensures SMBs get robust protection while staying compliant.

Implementation Requirements and Costs

When diving into practical use cases, understanding the requirements and costs involved in implementation is crucial for picking the right solution.

Price Comparison

The cost of SIEM and XDR solutions varies based on how extensively they are deployed and the amount of data they handle. To make an informed choice, organizations should consider the total cost of ownership. This includes setup fees, licensing, storage, and ongoing maintenance. It's also a good idea to request customized quotes to get a clearer picture. For businesses working with limited resources, LogCentral's cloud-based solution stands out as a budget-friendly and scalable option.

French Data Protection Rules

For small and medium-sized businesses (SMBs) in France, adhering to data protection regulations is non-negotiable. Key compliance areas include:

• Data Retention and Protection: Security logs must be stored in line with regulations, using encryption both during transmission and while at rest.

• Access Control Measures: Implement role-based access control (RBAC) and audit trails to track user activities and safeguard sensitive data.

• Incident Response Protocols: Have documented response plans in place, including adherence to GDPR's breach notification timelines.

Balancing these regulatory demands with the right deployment model is essential to ensure smooth and compliant operations.

Cloud-Based Options

Cloud-based security platforms bring flexibility and efficiency to the table, making them a strong option for many businesses. Here's why:

• Data Residency: LogCentral operates data centers within the EU, ensuring compliance with data sovereignty rules.

• Integration Capabilities: Effective solutions should seamlessly connect with existing security systems, focusing on endpoints, identity management, and email security.

• Scalability: LogCentral's platform adjusts automatically to usage demands, maintaining peak performance without manual intervention.

When evaluating vendors, look for those with clear, actionable plans and a commitment to continually improving their security offerings. This ensures the solution remains reliable and effective over time.

Making the Final Choice

Decision Points Summary

When deciding between SIEM and XDR, keep these critical considerations in mind:

Assess Your Core Needs:

• Compliance requirements: SIEM is essential if you need detailed audit trails and long-term data storage.

• Threat detection: XDR shines in automated detection across multiple endpoints.

• Resource availability: Factor in both the cost of implementation and ongoing operations.

• Compatibility: Ensure the tool integrates smoothly with your existing systems.

It's worth noting that XDR has expanded to include many functions traditionally associated with SIEM [1].

Selection Guide

Based on your specific needs, here's how to make the right choice:

Opt for SIEM if:

• Your focus is on meeting compliance mandates, creating tailored alerts, and retaining logs over extended periods.

Opt for XDR if:

• You value automated threat identification, robust endpoint protection, and analytics powered by AI.

Consider a Hybrid Approach if:

• You require both compliance capabilities and advanced threat detection but want to avoid operational disruptions.

When evaluating potential solutions, look for:

• A clear roadmap for AI advancements.

• Strong endpoint detection and response features.

• Data centres located within the EU.

• Flexible and scalable pricing structures.

Keep in mind that while XDR offers impressive advancements, it may not fully replicate the compliance and customisation strengths of SIEM.

[1] Reference: Key industry research on the evolution of XDR capabilities.

FAQs

::: faq

How can SMBs decide if a hybrid SIEM-XDR solution is the right fit for their cybersecurity needs?

To figure out if a hybrid SIEM-XDR solution fits your SMB's security needs, start by identifying your key priorities. If compliance reporting, long-term data storage, or customisable log analysis are at the top of your list, a SIEM might be a must-have. On the flip side, if your focus is on automated threat detection across endpoints, networks, and the cloud, XDR brings advanced, AI-powered tools to the table.

A hybrid approach could be the perfect middle ground if your business demands both: the comprehensive log management and reporting capabilities of a SIEM, paired with the proactive, integrated threat detection of XDR. Take a close look at your IT team's capacity, how complex your infrastructure is, and your financial constraints to decide what works best for the challenges of 2025. :::

::: faq

How does the cost of a cloud-based XDR solution compare to a traditional SIEM system for SMBs?

The cost of choosing a cloud-based XDR solution versus a traditional SIEM system depends heavily on factors like the size of your organisation, its security requirements, and the infrastructure already in place. XDR solutions often include built-in automation and AI-powered analytics, which can minimise the need for manual intervention and help cut operational costs over time. That said, these solutions may come with higher initial subscription fees, especially if you’re looking for advanced features.

In contrast, SIEM systems are well-regarded for their customisation and flexibility. However, they typically demand more resources for setup, ongoing maintenance, and compliance tasks. For smaller businesses with limited resources, a cloud-based SIEM-as-a-service or even a hybrid approach that combines SIEM and XDR might strike a better balance between cost and performance. Evaluating your long-term monitoring and compliance needs is crucial to finding the solution that works best for your budget and goals. :::

::: faq

How does LogCentral comply with French data protection laws when offering its cloud-based security platform?

LogCentral is dedicated to adhering to French data protection laws, including the GDPR (Règlement Général sur la Protection des Données). Our cloud-based platform operates from secure, GDPR-compliant data centres located within the EU, ensuring your data is safeguarded under European regulations.

To support businesses in meeting data security and privacy requirements, our platform offers powerful tools such as data encryption, access controls, and audit trails. We also enable long-term log retention and provide detailed compliance reporting, helping you stay in step with French legal obligations and industry standards. :::